Which is better?

Well, me and a friends had a kinda signature duel thing and this is the result. We can't decide which is better so i'm going to leave it to you guys.

Which one is better and why?



EDIT: I voted for mine because I just like it better.

[DarkPacMan77]

The font on #1 sucks.

-DarkPacMan77-

wow.... i need to practice.... coz even the first one looks better than all Ive done

#2 has the nice shadow effect.

[ace]

I guess bottom one since, well idk I just like the fractal effect around the render.
Man i need to get back into making sigs again, after like the first 2 I made XD.

I vote #2, i dont like the font on the 1st one, and i dont like that transparent black box around part of it.

I voted #2...

what wrong with the first one.. well, that transparent box for one it makes it look like the sig has been beveled thus giving it the look of a giant button or giant space bar. The font could have been better. It pretty much looks like this.... a super large render as the background, followed by 2 smaller versions of the render one of which is overlayed...In other words, it looks like you just slapped everything together.

Anyways...number 2 wins

Wewt, my one won! Mine took me a while to make but my friends one took less than 5 mins so that kinda explains why it looks slapped together.